|
Molded-Case
Circuit Breaker
|
Supplementary
Protector
|
| In testing, must be
able to interrupt its rated fault current and remain operational after the fault. |
In testing, only may
need to interrupt an overcurrent; may be nonoperational after a fault current is imposed. |
| Intended to provide
conductor protection in accordance with the National Electrical Code (NEC). |
Not evaluated to provide
conductor protection and cannot be used in branch circuits. |
| Not allowed to rely
on a series protective device for conductor protection. |
Allowed to be tested
with a branch-circuit device in series with the supplementary protector. |
| Required to protect downstream wiring and appliances. | Used
in an appliance; may provide some wiring and appliance protection. |
| Cannot rely on other
devices to provide overcurrent protection as defined in the NEC. |
May rely on a separate
device to assist with short-circuit |
| Has minimum short-circuit-interrupting
ratings of 5000 A at 250 V ac and 10,000 A at above 250 V ac. |
Has a typical maximum
short-circuit current rating of 5000 A, but need not have been evaluated for short-circuit conditions during the recognition. May be evaluated for greater than 5000 A and may be evaluated at any value declared by the manufacturer. |
| Typically mounts in listed circuit-breaker panelboards. | Typically
mounts (as a component of a listed assembly) in appliances or on DIN rails and is typically smaller than a molded-case circuit breaker. |
| Always listed (but
beware of confusion of a listed motor control with a listed molded-case circuit breaker). |
A recognized component. |
| Required to close on fault conditions. | Typically not required to close on fault conditions. |
| Has trip-curve characteristics
developed for protection of branch and feeder circuits. |
Has no standard trip
curve established by the product safety standard to ensure protection of conductors in the event of an overload or short-circuit condition. |
| Carries no conditions of use (acceptability). | Carries specific conditions
for use (acceptability) that must be followed to ensure that the device will meet minimum electrical fire and shock requirements. |
|
Table I. A point-by-point comparison of the application conditions and requirements of molded-case circuit breakers and supplementary protectors. |