CE
Compliance Engineering
search
Join Our Discussions
Find Suppliers Useful Links
calendar
Click
here for information on advertisers and products!
About CE-Mag
Free Subscriptions
Current Issue
Article Archives
ESD Help
Mr. Static
Web Gallery
Staff Info
Contact us

 

 

 

Addressing EMI Shielding Problems with Specially Engineered Materials

Jerry English

Innovative materials can provide a solution to heat-dissipation and weight issues encountered in automotive, telecommunications, and other applications.

A compartmentalized shield with an easy-to-remove perforated top section. The cut-away allows for easy repair of the shielded component.

Automobile manufacturers are introducing new cars that promise to be faster, more efficient, and more sophisticated than ever. Much of the increased sophistication is due to the growth of telematics, the blending of computers and telecommunications. In the automotive field, telematics is used to provide additional information and control to the driver. Some of these features include navigation systems, real-time traffic information, satellite radio, road-condition sensing, remote door openers, electronic toll collection, adaptive cruise control, and collision warning systems.

Next-generation automotive applications might include Bluetooth technology as a connectivity solution for portable devices and in-vehicle electronic systems. A possible application would be a Bluetooth-based hands-free cellular phone.

Table I provides an overview of typical operating frequencies for Bluetooth and other wireless automotive devices. All of these devices and systems are susceptible to electromagnetic interference (EMI). If not properly contained, EMI not only causes a device's own circuitry to malfunction but also affects the performance of other devices that are in close proximity.

Government agencies, such as the Federal Communications Commission (FCC), set specific requirements to limit EMI emissions from electronic devices. These requirements ensure that, under most circumstances, electronic devices will not interfere with one another. Moreover, automobile manufacturers have their own standards and specifications that these devices must meet. To meet the standards, manufacturers often need to make certain that devices are properly shielded. To address this problem, manufacturers employ a variety of shielding techniques to diminish EMI. As board-level components become more tightly packed on a board, shielding needs increase and surface-mount shielding options become the preferred method of shielding.

Engineers need to address many board-level EMI shielding issues, including the material composition, design, production, installation, and cost of the shields. With manufacturers' greater emphasis on speed and profitability, the need for cost-effective and efficient EMI shielding is greater than ever.

Shielding Materials

Surface-mount shields are made from a variety of metals and can be plated with tin or other solderable materials as needed. Common shielding materials include copper, BMI's (Schaumburg, IL) Shield Lite, aluminum 6061, brass, beryllium copper, iron, magnesium AZ91D, cold-rolled steel, nickel silver, and Permalloy 80 (see Table II for the pertinent properties of these materials).

Technology Typical Operating Frequency
Bluetooth 2.4­2.483 GHz
Satellite radio 2.32­2.34 GHz
Electronic toll collection 900­928 MHz (U.S. only)
2.45 GHz
5.8 GHz
Adaptive cruise control 35, 60, and 86 GHz
76­77 GHz (globally)
Collision warning systems 76­77 GHz
Remote door openers 300­960 MHz
Table I. A selection of wireless technologies and their typical operating frequencies.

Shielding Effectiveness. The shielding performance of different materials can be analyzed using the transmission theory of shielding first derived by S. A. Schelkunoff.1 The transmission theory examines an incident plane wave onto a flat shield. The shielding performance has two major components: absorption and reflection. The absorption losses (measured in dB) in the shield material can be written as

Aa @ 132 t (f µr Kr)1/2, (1)

where t is the thickness, f is the frequency, µr is the relative magnetic permeability, and Kr is the relative conductivity of the material (expressed as a percentage of the International Annealed Copper Standard [%IACS], with copper = 1.00). It can be deduced from Equation 1 that the absorption component depends on the material thickness, electrical conductivity, magnetic permeability, and frequency of concern.

The reflection losses (measured in dB) occurring at the shield-air interface can be written as

Ar = 168 + 10 log (Kr f­1 µr­1). (2)

These equations show that, at lower frequencies, reflection losses dominate, and at higher frequencies, absorption losses dominate, especially for thicker shields.

In actual service conditions, often other parameters are the limiting factor for shielding effectiveness. As shown in Figure 1, the theoretical shielding effectiveness for the materials examined is greater than 100 dB, whereas in practice, lower values are observed because of the nonideality of the system and the presence of openings and apertures.

Material Density (g/cm3) Relative Magnetic
Permeability µr (rounded)
Relative Conductance Kr Thermal Conductivity
(W / [m·K])
Pure copper 8.92 1 1.00 391
Shield Lite (BMI) 3.32 1 0.40 190
Aluminum 6061 2.70 1 0.46 180
Brass 8.53 1 0.28 120
Beryllium copper 8.36 1 0.20 105
Pure iron 7.87 1000 0.17 76
Magnesium AZ91D 1.81 1 0.12 72
Cold-rolled steel 7.87 200 0.12 50
Nickel silver 8.70 1 0.06 29
Permalloy 80 8.74 75,000 0.04 20
Table II. Properties of some common shielding materials.

Weight. In the past, the densities of materials used in surface-mount shielding were greater than 8 g/cm3. The high density can increase the overall weight of the board to unacceptable levels. Recent breakthroughs have allowed a reduction in density (and weight) without sacrificing the effectiveness of the shield.

Heat Dissipation. Another issue manufacturers face when designing the composition of shields is how to address the level of heat emitted by electronic devices. The operating temperature of circuitry can reach high levels and, if not properly managed, thermal stress can cause system malfunction. In various attempts to reduce heat within devices, special materials have been created with enhanced thermal conductive properties that help to dissipate the heat generated by the electronics, resulting in increased reliability.

Time to Market

Surface-mount technology has quickly become one of the easiest and most cost-effective ways to install components onto circuit boards in an assembly line system. Existing standard pick-and-place equipment can place the board-level, surface-mount shields just prior to reflow, after all the other components have been placed. Surface-mount shields can even be used on double-sided boards and are compatible with the new lead-free reflow processes. This allows the boards to be manufactured quickly and inexpensively.

Solving Shielding Problems

Shielding designers continue to work to overcome a variety of EMI obstacles. Through relationships with industry leaders in cellular phone, nonvoice wireless, computer, medical electronics, and automotive technology, many innovative products have been created that tackle key issues such as weight, heat, size, production, and cost.

For example, BMI had an automotive customer that required shielding in a wireless controller that operates garage doors and similar devices from within the automobile. Space was an issue because the component positions were fixed on the circuit board and could not be redesigned. Without the shielding, the transmitting antenna would couple with the voltage-controlled oscillator (VCO), causing the device to malfunction. To solve the problem, a shield was placed over the VCO circuit group to decouple it from the antenna, meeting the device's space requirements.

Figure 1. Theoretical shielding effectiveness (SE) for cold-rolled steel (CRS), nickel silver (NS), and Shield Lite (SL).

To meet the weight-reduction demands of modern electronic devices, a product is needed that is half as dense as traditional materials. EMI shields using a specially engineered material provide a lightweight solution. Such shielding also offers enhanced thermal properties, effectively removing the heat generated from circuit boards, providing better long-term reliability.

Multicompartment shields customized for each device are another solution to modern shielding problems. One multicompartment shield can take the place of three or more individual shields, consolidating space in small devices.

In addition to solving issues of space constraint, this type of shielding has benefits in production and cost. For example, there is no longer a need to maintain and manage several shield inventories because each multicompartment shield is specifically designed to replace multiple shields. Furthermore, multicompartment shields have a single-process installation, which reduces cost and simplifies a manufacturer's production.

Conclusion

Overall, the returns on the use of EMI shielding remain positive with continuous improvements in technology. In modern devices, the importance of selecting proper shielding for each unique application has increased.

For example, as automotive electronics technology evolves and advances with the increased application of wireless systems, more-innovative shielding options will be required for safe and seamless functioning. Knowledgeable and experienced suppliers are key to meeting these shielding needs.

Reference

1. SA Schelkunoff, Electromagnetic Waves (New York: Van Nostrand, 1943), 530.

Jerry English is the director of advanced products at BMI Inc. (Schaumburg, IL). He can be contacted at 847-839-6000 or info@bmiinc.com