The Taiwanese EMC Standard CNS 13803
Compared with CISPR 11
Michael J. Alvarado and Grace Lin
The national standard varies from the source standard
in ways that could
affect the ease of market entry in Taiwan.
The Taiwanese regulatory agency responsible for
EMC regulation, the Bureau of Standards, Metrology,
and Inspection (BSMI), has begun to implement EMC
requirements for industrial, scientific, and medical
(ISM) radio-frequency equipment. Such devices must
meet the requirements of the Chinese national standard
CNS 13803:1997 before they can be placed on the market
in Taiwan.
CNS 13803:1997 is similar to CISPR 11:1990, on which
it is based. Both standards are titled "Limits and
Methods of Measurement of Electromagnetic Disturbance
Characteristics of Industrial, Scientific, and Medical
(ISM) Radio-Frequency Equipment." But there are some
differences between the standards that, if not understood,
could delay receipt of EMC approval for a product
intended to be marketed in Taiwan. This article examines
the scope of CNS 13803, focusing on its deviations
from the CISPR standards. Table I itemizes the points
of difference between the International Electrotechnical
Commission (IEC) standard and its Taiwanese counterpart.
| Section |
CISPR 11:1990 |
CNS 13803:1997 |
| 1 |
Subsections 1.1, 1.2, 1.3, and 1.4
|
Not divided into subsections |
| 1.2 |
"There shall be 80% confidence that
at least 80% of manufactured items comply with
the limits given." |
Deleted |
| 2.2 |
"For the purpose of this publication
the definitions contained in IEC 50 (161) apply."
|
Deleted |
| 2.4 |
"The boundary of the equipment under
test ..." |
Text appears in Section 2.2 |
| 3 |
Center frequencies designated for ISM use in
MHz (frequency ranges in parentheses)
6.780 (6.7656.795)
13.560 (13.55313.567)
27.120 (26.95727.283)
40.680 (40.6640.70)
433.920 (433.05434.79)
915.000 (902928)
2450 (24002500)
5800 (57255875)
24,125 (24,00024,250)
61,250 (61,00061,500)
122,500 (122,000123,000)
245,000 (244,000246,000)
|
Center frequencies designated for
ISM use in MHz (frequency ranges in parentheses)
13.560 (13.53313.567)
27.120 (26.95727.283)
40.680 (40.6640.70)
2450 (24002500)
5800 (57255875)
24,125 (24,00024,250) |
| Table 1 |
Fourth column, headed "Number of
appropriate footnote to the table of frequency
allocation to the ITU Radio Regulation" |
Deleted |
Table 1,
Footnote 1
|
"Resolution No. 63 of the ITU Radio
Regulations applies." |
"Use of these ISM frequency ranges
shall not affect radio-frequency telecommunication." |
Table 1,
Footnote 2 |
"Use of these frequency bands is
subject to special authorization by ... might be
affected." |
"The term ŒUnrestricted¹ applies
to the fundamental and all other frequency components
falling within the designated band." |
Table 1,
Footnote 3 |
"The term ŒUnrestricted¹ applies
to the fundamental and all other frequency components
falling within the designated band. Special measures
to achieve compatibility may be necessary where
other equipment satisfying immunity requirements
is placed close to ISM equipment." |
"Special measures to achieve compatibility
may be necessary where other equipment satisfying
immunity requirements is placed close to ISM equipment." |
| 4 |
Annex A |
Annex 1 |
| 7.2.1 |
CISPR 16
Annex B |
CNS 13306
Annex 2 |
| 7.2.2 |
CISPR 16 |
CNS 13306 |
| 7.2.4 |
CISPR 16
CISPR 19 |
CNS 13306
CNS 13804 |
| 7.4.2(a) |
IEC 83 |
CNS 960 |
| 7.5.1.2 |
Note 2 |
Deleted |
| 7.5.1.3 |
Note |
Deleted |
| 8 (Note) |
CISPR 19 |
CNS 13804 |
| 8.1.1 |
(Note) CISPR 16 |
CNS 13305 |
| 9.4 (Note) |
CISPR 19 |
CNS 13804 |
| 10 (Note) |
CISPR 19 |
CNS 13804 |
| Annex 5 1 |
Not applicable |
Determination of limits for industrial,
scientific, and medical equipment (in reference
to CISPR 23:1987) |
| 1CNS 13803:1997 designation only |
| Table I. A comparison of CNS
13803:1997 and CISPR 11:1990, listing significant
points of difference in arrangement and content.
Section numbers pertain to both CNS 13803 and
CISPR 11 in cases of variance except where noted. |
ISM Frequencies
The ISM-designated frequency bands are exempted
from emission requirements in both CNS 13803 and CISPR
11. This means that there are no radiation limitations
for frequencies falling within the designated ranges.
CNS 13803 specifies 6 ISM frequencies, by contrast
with the 12 specified by CISPR 11, because the Taiwanese
Directorate General of Telecommunications allocated
only that many bands. Thus, products designed in accordance
with CISPR 11 requirements may not comply with CNS
13803 requirements, depending on their ISM-designated
frequencies. (See the part of Table I pertaining to
Section 3 of the standards.)
Annexes to the Standards
CNS 13803 has five annexes, numbered 1 through 5,
whereas CISPR 11 refers to its four annexes as A,
B, C, and D. The first four CNS 13803 annexes are
equivalent to the CISPR 11 annexes.
The fifth CNS 13803 annex is based on CISPR 23:1987;
four annexes were taken from CISPR 23 to make up Annex
5 of CNS 13803, which provides background on the determination
of limits for ISM equipment.
Measurement Distance
BSMI accepts test data for Group 2 Class A equipment
taken at the 10-m measurement distance and adjusted
by the interpolation method (L2
= L1[d1/d2])
for the radiation disturbance limits (as specified
in CISPR 22:1997, "Information Technology EquipmentRadio
Disturbance CharacteristicsLimits and Methods
of Measurement"). This alternate method is allowable
owing to the population density of Taiwan. A 30-m
test facility is not practical on the crowded island.
CISPR 11 allows measurements made at a closer distance,
but "no correction is allowed for in the limits."
This closer distance is defined as the distance between
the equipment under test and the measuring antenna.
Test Report
An EMC-compliance test report must include the information
specified in Section 13, "Certificates and Reports,"
of ISO Guide 25, "General Requirements for the Competence
of Calibration and Testing Laboratories," 1990.
A test laboratory is qualified to issue a CNS 13803
report only after obtaining accreditation from the
BSMI. CNS 13803 is within the scope of the mutual
recognition agreement between Taiwan and the United
States that became effective August 1, 1999. However,
no test laboratories in the United States are applying
for accreditation for this standard at this time.
Currently, only five EMC test laboratories are accredited
by the BSMI to perform EMC compliance testing for
CNS 13803. They are all located in Taiwan. Information
about them can be found at the BSMI Web site (http://www.bsmi.gov.tw).
BSMI-accredited test laboratories qualified to perform
CNS 13803 testing are assigned an accreditation number
with the format SL2-IS-E-XXXX, the numerals in the
last four positions denoting the particular laboratory.
Type Approval
Manufacturers and importers are required to apply
for a BSMI type approval for regulated products they
wish to market in Taiwan. The type-approval procedure
is spelled out at the BSMI Web site. In addition to
a test report, five technical documents must be submitted
with the application: a user manual, the BSMI label
location, a block diagram, EMC modifications and clock
frequencies, and a product catalog and photographs.
These required documents could be part of the test
report.
Conclusion
ISM frequencies should be the main concern when
a product intended for the Taiwanese market is designed.
The safe way to design such a product is to use one
of the ISM-designated frequency bands specified in
CNS 13803 and CISPR 11 in common.
The first two categories of regulated industrial
and scientific products mandated to comply with the
EMC requirementseffective date: July 1, 2000are
microwave ovens and electric- magnetic cookers. These
products are also regulated for use in residential
environments.
The BSMI has not addressed EMC requirements for
medical equipment at this time. A revised version
of CNS 13803, referencing CISPR 11:1997, is under
consideration.
Acknowledgments
The authors wish to thank Yung-Chi Tang and Han-Chang
Hsieh of BSMI and Roland W. Gubisch, PhD, of Intertek
Testing Services NA Inc. for their assistance in the
preparation of this article.
Michael J. Alvarado and Grace Lin are senior
project engineers at Intertek Testing Services NA
Inc. (Duluth, GA). They can be reached at malvarado@itsqs.com
and glin@itsqs.com, respectively.